We tried AI travel planning. It handed us homework

IMG_7920

AI travel planning is having a moment. Meta has Muse, and OpenAI has Dots. The pitch for both: hand over the task and go live your life. Booking your next trip is the example everyone loves.

Naturally, we had to try it. Partly out of curiosity, and partly, we will admit, to see whether we still had jobs. So we gave AI a trip (several AIs, several trips).

The answers came back fast, cheerful, and long: hotels by the dozen, restaurants by neighborhood, and flights at every hour of the day. Then, at the bottom, every single time, came the same sweet question: which would you like? We asked for a trip. Instead, we got homework.

150 options is a second job

You run a team, or argue cases, or ship products. Your calendar was full before this trip ever came up.

So a list of 150 options is a gift you have to assemble yourself. Someone still has to read the reviews, compare the rooms, check the landing time against the dinner reservation, and choose. That someone is you, at 11pm, with 47 tabs open and no trip.

We know, because it happened to us. Somewhere around the third list, we caught ourselves opening tabs, cross-checking, and second-guessing a hotel we had liked ten minutes earlier. In other words, the tool built to save time had handed us a research project.

The hours are one cost. Arriving tired of a trip you have yet to take is another.

It is also the same list everybody else gets. AI knows what the internet thinks of Paris. It has never met you. Then again, it has never been to Paris either.

So it has no idea that a 6am flight ruins your whole first day, that you want the quiet pool, or that your partner will not, under any circumstances, get on a boat.

To be fair, the tools are fast, and they are good at search: flight times, packing lists, a menu translated in seconds. So use them for that.

Search was always the easy part. Choosing is the hard part, because choosing well takes someone who knows you.

Then an airline said no

In November, United Airlines told AI agents they are no longer welcome to book, change, or manage its tickets. The airline’s concerns: your privacy, your account, and purchases you never approved.

A ticket booked by a bot can now be canceled without warning. Imagine learning that at the check-in desk.

Other airlines are writing their own rules, and those rules keep moving. Still, under all of it sits the oldest question in travel: when something breaks, who answers for it?

You know the loop. The flight cancels. Then the airline sends you to the website, and the website sends you to a chatbot. Meanwhile, your phone is at 9% and the gate agent is putting on her coat. (If you have ever explained a canceled flight to a chatbot, you have our sympathy.)

A bot can click “buy.” Staying with you through what happens next is a different job. After all, software has terms of service. A person has a phone number.

One person who knows how you travel

Our clients live outside that loop. When something changes, they have a person who knows the whole trip. Some of them never lift a finger.

How we set that up is our business. Literally.

Here is the part we will say out loud. You can have 150 options thrown at you, or you can have one person who knows how you like to travel and has already done the thinking.

We get to know you. Then we go away, do the work, and come back with one answer: your trip, with the decisions already made. After that, you read it, say yes, and go back to your week.

Travel built for one person feels different from the first hour. The pace fits, and so does the room. Nothing is there because an algorithm ranked it fourth.

There is one rule we will share, because it is the one we are proudest of. We only design travel to places we have been ourselves. That is 50+ countries so far, with France and Brazil at the top of the list.

AI has read the reviews. We have unpacked the suitcase.

The rest of the recipe stays in the kitchen. You still get dinner.

Some things deserve a person

Busy people already live this way: a lawyer, an accountant, a trainer. Your time off also belongs on that list.

And yes, we see it: a travel design and experience firm concluding that you need a travel design and experience firm. Shocking.

So here is the takeaway, free of charge. Let AI fetch: flight times, translations, the packing list. Then give the deciding to someone who knows you and who picks up when the day goes sideways.

Bring us the 47 open tabs. We’ll take it from there.

You know you love us.